Though much of this book is devoted to impugning all the standard rationales for capital punishment, the chief purpose of the volume is to advance an alternative. The case against capital punishment is often made on the basis that society has a moral obligation to protect human life, not take it. This book explodes this myth that americas founders were ardent advocates of capital punishment. Countries employing capital punishment classifies death penalty depending on the virtue ethics present in the specific country. Capital punishment reduces crime in some aspects, but it also is taking the life away from the criminal. The death penalty is ethical since it is the only form of retribution when a person commits a heinous crime. Essays on theory and policy, featuring a dozen prominent legal scholars and philosophers presenting new interpretatations, extensions, and applications of retributivism, broadly defined as the view that punishment is justified and motivated by considerations of justice, rights, and desert. The sentence ordering that someone be punished in such a manner is referred to as a death sentence, whereas the act of carrying out such a sentence is known as an execution.
Instead it shows the founders conflicting and ambivalent views on capital punishment. This is a fascinating book in that kramer, professor of legal and political philosophy at cambridge, is able to generate a counter. Intervarsity press, 2002, and on the capital punishment work group was extremely helpful and is reflected throughout this study. In fact, the principle of capital punishment even precedes the old testament law code. The current debate surrounding capital punishment is complicated and involves legal, civil, philosophical, and religious issues. It is the judicial execution of criminals judged guilty of capital offenses by the state, or in other words, the death penalty. Debate has long been waged over the morality of capital punishment, with standard arguments in its favour being marshalled against familiar. Apr 17, 2009 the ethics of capital punishment synopsis. The ethics of capital punishment essay 1125 words bartleby. Not only does it offer a thorough and uptodate discussion of traditional justifications for the death penalty, it also attempts to offer an alternative, novel justification for it, something that. I hope to demonstrate this by examining how the ethics of care might deal with the topic of punishment. Original, unsettling, and deeply controversial, it will be an essential reference point for future debates on the subject. The ethics of capital punishment by christine watkins.
I think the whole issue of capital punishment comes down to a question of whether or not there is an unconditional right to life. This makes it interrelated with a host of other issues. Capital punishment, or the death penalty, is an institutionalized practice. The book pursues both a project of critical debunking of the familiar rationales for capital punishment and a project of partial vindication.
Relating this to capital punishment or death penalty, it may be said that as according to kants theory, a crime that is proven to be driven by desires and done without rationalization is immoral and therefore may be considered as deserving of capital punishment. Capital punishment internet encyclopedia of philosophy. The ethics of capital punishment by matthew kramer, 9780199642199, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. This anthology explores the ethical arguments involved, from the rights of the condemned to the rights of their victims, and to the rights of society as a whole. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read the ethics of capital punishment. Even among those professing christian faith, there is widespread opposition to the death penalty. A philosophical investigation of evil and its consequences ebook written by matthew h. Consequently, this book s contestation of the prevailing rationales for the death penalty will address them predominantly as just such rationales rather than as doc. The critical part presents an accessible and engaging critique of major arguments that have been offered from the deterrence of future wrongdoing to the justice of retributory killing arguing that.
Read the ethics of capital punishment a zondervan digital short by scott rae available from rakuten kobo. Capital punishment has many different ethical issues involved in it and paper masters can custom write a research paper on any of the sociological arguments that favor capital punishment. The question as to whether or not it is morally acceptable for the state to execute people, and if so under what circumstances, has been debated for centuries. Contemporary culture, in contrast, is permeated with arguments against capital punishment. Contemporary case studies throughout the book illustrate ethical issues and theories in applied terms. The question as to whether or not it is morally acceptable for the state to execute people, and if so under what circumstances, has been debated for. Ethics govern a persons behavior, and when a person is planning on committing a crime, they should already know that their actions will be in violation of the policies and laws that govern the state or country that they plan on. Through my ethics class, i have learned that the best way to evaluate morality is to look at three things. In kants day, capital punishment was used for a variety of crimes through out europe and the. Kant and capital punishment today unl digital commons. Historically, the church has affirmed the right of the civil magistrate in matters of capital justice. Not only does it offer a thorough and uptodate discussion of traditional. The ethics of capital punishment christian research institute.
The ethics of capital punishment ebook by scott rae. Presents accessible critiques of the standard arguments advanced for the death penalty, making valuable introductory reading for students studying the topic. The argument that capital punishment deters crime is hard to prove, but would be an argument in favor for utilitarianism, but just as the categorical imperative fails logically, the execution of the innocent can be justified in. Capital punishment, also known as the death penalty, is a governmentsanctioned practice whereby a person is put to death by the state as a punishment for a crime. The argument that capital punishment deters crime is hard to prove, but would be an argument in favor for utilitarianism, but just as the categorical imperative. The ethics of capital punishment wiley online library.
Dialogues on the ethics of capital punishment by dale jacquette. The old testament also teaches that god instituted capital punishment in the jewish law code. Raes widely adopted textbook, moral choices, this digital short looks carefully at the bibles te. A zondervan digital short ebook written by scott rae. The ethics of capital punishment by christine watkins goodreads. A code of ethics for various roles in the criminal justice system i. Not only does it offer a thorough and uptodate discussion of traditional justifications for the death penalty, it also attempts to offer an alternative, novel justification for it, something that kramer calls the purgative rationale.
This book, written in the form of a dialogue, is an introduction to several ethical theories and to four major contemporary moral issues. In the ethics of capital punishment, matthew kramer takes a fresh look at the philosophical arguments on which the legitimacy of the death penalty stands or falls, and he develops a novel justification of that penalty for a limited range of cases. Capital punishment is against the best judgment of modern criminology and, above all, against the highest expression of love in the nature of god. These books provide a range of opinions on a social issue. For example, if i believe there is an unconditional right to life, can i ethically justify continuing to be excellent book. The purely ethical argument for capital punishment is discussed by many research papers on the death penalty. A compendium of opinion on the moral and ethical issues surrounding capital punishment, including whether it deters murder and whether its too expensive to retain. The ethics of capital punishment by nick fisanick and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at. Capital punishment is the practice of executing someone as punishment for a specific crime after a proper legal trial. First, as joe and i show in our book, aquinass fundamental reason for endorsing capital punishment is not what tollefsen supposes it to be. Matthew kramers book the ethics of capital punishment is a significant achievement. Nov 28, 2008 i think the whole issue of capital punishment comes down to a question of whether or not there is an unconditional right to life. Download pdf dialoguesontheethicsofcapitalpunishment.
The taking of human life is permissible only if it is a necessary condition to achieving the greatest balance of good over evil for everyone involved. Debate has long been waged over the morality of capital punishment, with standard arguments in its favor, grounded in the values of retribution or deterrence. Given the value we place on life and our obligation to. Coming in april from oxford university press is my latest edited volume, retributivism.
Those against it usually center their arguments on the morality of capital punishment. The ethics of capital punishment a philosophical investigation of evil and its consequences matthew h. The ethics of capital punishment matthew kramer oxford. A philosophical investigation of evil and its consequences. The ethics of capital punishment professional bookshop. For example, some countries reserved death penalty for murder and treason while other countries direct death penalty for sexual crimes rape, human and drug trafficking. Though much of this book is devoted to impugning all the standard rationales for capital punishment, the chief purpose of the volume is to advance an alternative justification for such punishment in a very limited range of cases. The ethics of capital punishment ethics is the study of standards of right and wrong. The first established death penalty laws can date back to the eighteenth century b. The ethics of capital punishment essay 1125 words 5 pages. Taking a fresh look at a central controversy in criminal law theory, the ethics of capital punishment presents a rationale for the death penalty grounded in a theory of the nature of evil and the nature of defilement. I do know that if a member of my family or a close friend was murdered, my behavior would be. I do know that if a member of my family or a close friend was murdered, my behavior would be profoundly influenced by emotion.
409 863 964 160 1333 321 452 1471 82 214 673 403 1181 134 946 1102 101 791 50 770 828 59 464 1302 1001 692 554 91 56 374 482 1493 643 1045 483 1225 500 153